Note: While I am a proud resident of Richmond, Va at the moment, and have lived most recently in St. Louis, Louisville and DC, I am a native Northeast Ohioan, and therefore eagerly await October, marking as it does the first appearance for the Tribe in the postseason since 2001 (and the first appearance in the postseason with a real pitching staff since 1954). Expect more like this, earned on all those drizzly April evenings on which you could count the crowd at Municipal Stadium.
Pretend you’re the Manager, part 1: Your lineup card has two empty spots remaining. Pick from the following three alternatives:
Player BA OBP SLG OPS+ HR RBI
Player A .300 .374 .507 133 25 111
Player B .293 .363 .489 126 21 61
Player C .253 .304 .468 103 7 30
Assuming you didn’t peek, the three choices are Victor Martinez, Ryan Garko and Kelly Shoppach, respectively. Unfortunately, when Paul Byrd pitches, the Indians braintrust benches Garko to make room for Byrd’s “personal catcher.” This greatly diminishes the offensive statistics of the lineup (although, to be fair, Shoppach is a better defensive backstop than Martinez, as the two CS in last night’s game will attest). Thus, Byrd’s latest effort, which likely solidified the #3 spot against the Yankees for Jake Westbrook, did the whole team a favor, even if it blew an opportunity to move up a game on the BoSox for the AL’s best record.
Byrd’s been an asset overall, of course, turning around the disaster of 2006. Given the complete meltdowns of Sowers and Lee, those 15 wins are huge. But he’s clearly wearing down and becoming less effective. Since his last good start, a complete game shutout of the hapless White Sox on September 1, here’s Byrd’s line:
W L IP H R ER BB SO HR ERA 1 3 29 44 23 22 5 11 6 6.83
By way of comparison, here’s Jake Westbrook over the same 5-start period:
W L IP H R ER BB SO HR ERA 1 2 30.2 39 17 14 13 26 3 4.11
Jake’s not all that great, either, but OK as a 3rd starter behind Sabathia and Carmona. And in a five game series, it means the Tribe can throw out quality starters for all five games, and need not bench one of their two most consistent hitters to do so.